"Most smart people ignore most advertising because most advertising ignores smart people."

—Bill Bernbach, the legendary 'B' in DDB.

Ethical question: Is newsjacking black hat?

Posted: November 19th, 2011 | Author: | Filed under: Brand Journalism, Interactive Marketing | Tags: , , , , , | 47 Comments »

Newsjacking: a PR/marketing practice wherein a brand creates content around a current news story to “inject their ideas,” with the intention that reporters will find it by Googling keywords/searching hashtags & include it to flesh out their articles or present a fresh angle.

Black hat: achieving goals in an unethical or deceptive manner. For the purpose of this discussion, we’ll define it as “an ethical frowny face“.

Kenneth Cole newsjacks, and then wishes he didn't.I have no idea how PR people did their jobs before the internet, but nowadays all smart marketers newsjack a little.

We stuff craft headlines with current keywords. We comment on trending topics and hashtag our thoughts so they make it into the Main Stream. We raffle off tickets to our big deal sports franchise and run ads with our city’s celebrities, because they’re hot & they get people’s attention.

Newsjacking proper, as very recently coined in David Meerman Scott‘s new booklet Newsjacking: How to Inject Your Ideas into a Breaking News Story & Get Tons of Media Coverage, makes the riding-popular-coattails concept overt: when news breaks that you can connect your brand to, do it. Fast. Use search—journalist’s search—to get earned media.

For PR folks, it means no longer offering their clients to the media for comment, but preparing that comment immediately, garnishing it with a topical linkbait headline & letting Google bring the media to them. It’s earned media predicated on reporter laziness/desperation.

Does newsjacking feel a little too black hat to you?
@EricaGlasier
Erica Glasier ♥
@ Newsjacking is not black hat. You're reacting to the name, not the practice.
@dmscott
David Meerman Scott

I’ve newsjacked.

I totally admit it, and it works. When Travel Manitoba released the ‘Manitoba Time’ slogan, I whipped up a visual reaction of a product: iPhone & desktop wallpapers. I even wrote an SEO-supercharged bald-faced lie as a headline, with a little asterisk to deflect culpability (I can do that; I’m not the media).

It's Manitoba Time!

Just like David Scott said they would, a journalist jumped on the content & blogged about it. My site saw many a hit. Earned media crowned my work “clever” and “fun” (it totally is).

And this sort of newsjacking—cultural commentary, contributing to and expanding on a meme, idea or event—seems valid. The creator gives something back to the conversation.

But are we comfy with our news being padded with product placement?

I avoid tabloid journalism because bias makes me angry. I believe anything wearing the badge of ‘news’ is honour-bound to be fair, because people who aren’t educated enough to see through spin will take opinion as fact. And they’ll have few defences against subtle advertising.

@ I'm reacting (naively, I'm sure) to the idea that our news contains product placements.
@EricaGlasier
Erica Glasier ♥

I know news and PR have a long relationship (but not enough about that relationship to write something glibly sarcastic. Put that in for me, willya?). The PR folks I’ve invited to comment have been rolling their eyes since the (coveted) second paragraph. “Erica,” they say gently, patting me on the head like a small, slow child, “things are the same as they ever were, just faster.”

It’s probably naive to think otherwise. I’ve been the subject of news articles and understand how crafted the images and quotes that go with them are. I know you need humans to make a good story.

So I ask my reporter friends to read between the attractively-spaced lines when you Google for a story. I know you need good stuff to get more eyeballs on your stories < sites < ads. But don’t get jacked.


I discovered David & his Newsjacking ebook on the Marketing Over Coffee podcast. Uneasy, I almost turned it off, but I’m glad I didn’t.


How NOT to be yourself on social media.

Posted: May 9th, 2011 | Author: | Filed under: Culture & Cultural Anthropology, Social Media Marketing, Tips, Tricks, How-To's & Top 10's | Tags: , , | 5 Comments »

Social media success ultimately comes from the same thing as general social success: be a fascinating, compelling, genuine, supercool human being. But unless you’re an art star whose career hinges on publicity at all costs, there’s a couple topics you wanna stay away from, like religion, politics, and stuff that makes the Twitterverse go (rightfully) nuts.

Today’s case study: Uptown Hockey, an NHL-level sports management firm, express their opinion of marriage.

The backstory

The disaster

Very sad to read Sean Avery's misguided support of same-gender "marriage". Legal or not, it will always be wrong.
@uptownhockey
Uptown Sports
To clarify. This is not hatred or bigotry towards gays. It is not intolerance in any way shape or form. I believe we are all equal...
@uptownhockey
Uptown Sports
But I believe in the sanctity of marriage between one man and one woman. This is my personal viewpoint. I Do not hate anyone.
@uptownhockey
Uptown Sports

The backlash

Hahaha... @ is going to lose all of their clients for being homophobic retards
@electr1cpanda
Electric Panda Music
I hope all NHL players represented by @ drop them as theur agents. Proud of Sean Avery for standing up to homophobes
@aaronFreeballs
Aaron Friedman
I thought @ job was to protect their clients. Instead they have created a shit storm for them with their homophobic hatred.
@ReaganMask
TheRealReaganMask
Well, @ just got fired. 'How to loose your job in 140 characters of less" #whenwillpeoplelearn
Sooooo is the @ twitter rant some kinda joke by an disgruntled intern? This can't be serious.#crashnburn
@FMA_Park59
Fahima Anwar
@ No, @'s Twitter is run by the company's VP. He is related to the president, who also agrees with the comment.
@YummyTreeSap
Patrick F.
@ = the perfect example of an orgs social media handler going rogue and creating chaos. Your rep the orgs beliefs, not your own.
@megfuryinc
Meg Black
Hey @ you see how your reps are assassinating YOUR reputation with their intolerance? cc @
@kelleyskar
Kelley Skar
Don Reynolds of @ 's email & phone #...tell him directly what you think of his "tolerance" ! uptownsports.ca">don@uptownsports.ca (905) 632-549
@ Looking forward to all of your players leaving your bigoted ass. Maybe John Rocker is in need of representation?
@dropoutfilms
Tyler Jackson
@ if it is your personal opinion why did you post it on your business twitter feed? #BigotsAreIdiotsToo #NotSharpestToolInShed
@IanRCrawford
Ian Crawford
Very sad to read @ 's misguided views on life. Hey everyone, let's all guess how many clients leave after this. #dbag
@ehlien
Billy Buskell
@ It's a good thing that you're one of the people who run this business because what you're doing is outright unprofessional.

The result

How did @ gain more followers for a fucking stupid comment?!?! For shame #twitter. #disappointed
@cenquist
cenquist

Branding is out of our hands, PR becomes the new content nexus

Posted: June 3rd, 2010 | Author: | Filed under: Social Media Marketing | Tags: , , | 2 Comments »

BP’s brand disaster is as large and ill-contained as its oil disaster. The popularity of @BPGlobalPR, a guerilla attack on BP’s lame brand disaster mitigation PR, shines a light on the death of brand in the age of social media.

“Branding” is a strategy to differentiate your product/org. To set it apart through look, experience, and “serendipitous” appearances in news (earned media) and awareness (advertising) streams.

What does “branding” mean when people disregard messaging? It means your product/org is judged based on its actions and public opinion thereof. Client-facing communications—marketing communications, PR, and brand interactions like special events—now need to centre on giving people something good to talk about.

  • Offering quality interactions (a great product, a great time, great customer service)
  • Inviting people to participate (cool projects that spark the imagination while repaying the community)
  • Communicating the successes of the brand (allowing brandvocates to tell their stories)

PR is now being thought of as a strategic content creation and dissemination tool. Shaping the brand through word-of-finger.